The Cost Of Loyalty
The owner asks why you’re giving away breakfast, upgrades and points when the OTA is cheaper. Here’s the math you need before you answer.
No one:
An owner looking into the P&L: “The OTA takes its commission and that’s it. Over here we’re giving away breakfast, upgrades and lounge access, handing out points, and paying agencies on top. How is that cheaper?”
Here’s the thing: he isn’t wrong to ask. He’s just working with half a ledger. Your job is to give him the other half.
I promised you this one in RevPAR Is Up. Margins Are Down. Bonus Received. Here it is.
Why the Owner Thinks the OTA Is Cheaper
Commission is one line, it comes with an invoice, and everyone can see it. Direct booking has no invoice. Its costs are spread across marketing, IT, rooms, F&B and the loyalty program, each in a different budget, owned by a different department. Nobody adds them up.
So the owner sees one clean number on one side and a pile of “free stuff” on the other. The pile always loses.
Where the Direct Costs Hide
Start with the costs of winning the booking:
- Website hosting and the booking engine
- SEO and the agencies that run it
- Paid search, including automated ad tools like Google’s Performance Max, plus paid social and destination ads (HSMAI’s Revenue Optimization board names these among the often-underestimated costs of distribution)
- CRM, email, analytics and loyalty software (Stay Insiders groups these as technology and services)
- Incentives to get guests to enrol on property
- Card fees on every payment
Then the costs of keeping the member:
- Points. They sit on the books as a liability, valued on how many will be redeemed (Stay Insiders).
- Redemption stays. A guest paying with points still uses the room, the housekeeping, the breakfast and the amenities. The reimbursement is often well below what a paying guest would have brought, and in one US owner-side analysis it was capped unless the hotel was close to full (Hospitality Net). Check how your program actually pays you, and compare it with the rate you could have sold that night.
- Tier benefits. Free breakfast, lounge access, upgrades, late checkout, welcome amenities and gifts. They cost more in peak periods, because every free upgrade is a room you could have sold.
- F&B and spa discounts for members.
- Member rates and required discounts. The same owner-side analysis points to these, plus loyalty fees on member reservations and brand performance marketing fees, as costs owners carry.
- The member check-in desk and the people who staff it.
- Sales team payroll and discounts. HSMAI flags these as costs that rarely make it into distribution cost models.
One trap sits across all of this: paying to win guests you already had. If you’re bidding on your own hotel’s name in paid search, you’re paying for bookings that might have come in free.
It Shows Up in Your ADR
Two things hit your reported rate before anyone has asked a question.
Redemption stays dilute ADR. In most hotels’ reporting, a guest staying on points is counted at what the program reimbursed you, not at the rate you could have sold. Your ADR, and anything built on it like your index in the comp set report (see What Is RGI in Hotels), ends up looking weaker than the business really is.
Member rates typically sit below the public rate. That’s the point of them. The public rate is what the OTAs show, so on the headline rate a direct member booking looks like the worse deal. That’s why the owner thinks the OTA is cheaper. Compare what is left after all costs, not the rate on the screen. Kalibri’s data shows member business booked direct can still come out ahead of OTA business on that basis, even with the discount.
Do the Sum
You don’t need a vendor for this. You need one month and a finance colleague.
- List every line from both lists above. If you can’t find the cost, write down which department would know.
- Add up the direct costs and divide by the number of direct room nights.
- Compare what the program reimburses you for redemption stays with the rate you could have sold for that room.
- Write down your OTA commission rate.
- Compare what is left after all costs for each channel (net ADR).
- Repeat every quarter.
If you want to go further, tools such as Juyo Analytics and Kalibri’s Hummingbird estimate cost reservation by reservation, though HSMAI notes that level of detail is resource-intensive.
What the Industry Data Says (and Why It Isn’t Your Data)
Kalibri Labs’ 2025 review of US hotels found that Brand.com still comes out ahead of OTAs on net ADR after commissions, channel fees and loyalty costs. That’s the direction your owner needs to hear.
It’s also an average for US branded hotels. Your hotel could be better or worse. The data won’t win the meeting for you. Your own sum will.
Direct booking isn’t free. It was never supposed to be. It’s supposed to be cheaper and more sustainable - it’s supposed to free hotels from over-reliance on the OTAs. Now you have a way to prove that it’s actually more profitable. And if it isn’t - you’ve got work to do.
xoxo, Bored Hotelier 😉
Comments ()